Thinking

Critical Thinking: how to read an argument and spot six everyday fallacies

How to read an everyday argument: find its conclusion and the reasons behind it, judge whether those reasons really support it, and spot six common fallacies in ordinary talk.

3 lessons, 18 steps

Get it on Google Play

What to ask when someone gives you a reason

A friend says to skip the new cafe because the queue was long. An advert says two million people already use an app, as if that proved the app works. Critical Thinking: Arguments and Fallacies is a short course on reading claims like these: what exactly is being argued, which reasons are offered for it, and whether those reasons really support it.

The course has three lessons. The first takes an argument apart. You find the conclusion and the premises, use words like because and therefore as clues without trusting them blindly, follow a chain where one conclusion becomes the reason for the next, and spell out a premise the speaker left unsaid. The second separates deductive arguments, which claim their conclusion must follow, from inductive ones, which claim only that it is likely. You judge whether an argument is valid and whether it is sound, and rank arguments built on surveys from weak to strong by the size of the sample and how it was chosen. The third covers six fallacies in everyday talk: ad hominem, straw man, false dilemma, appeal to popularity, slippery slope and post hoc reasoning.

Each lesson opens with a short explanation and then gives you six steps. You pick an answer or a label, put statements in order, or explain something in a few sentences of your own. When your answer is off, the AI tutor first asks a question about it, then gives a hint, then a partial step. Show solution is always available, and a four-question quiz before and after each lesson shows what changed.

This is one of the editorial courses in Ai Teacher. The problems and worked solutions were written in advance, and definitions were checked against the public sources listed below.

What you'll learn

  • Find the conclusion, the premises and any unstated premise of an argument
  • Tell valid from sound and strong from weak arguments
  • Recognise six common fallacies in everyday talk

Lessons

  1. Parts of an argument

    6 steps, 4 min intro

  2. Deductive and inductive arguments

    6 steps, 4 min intro

  3. Common fallacies in everyday talk

    6 steps, 4 min intro

A step from lesson 3

Tutor: Tomas started wearing his blue socks to every match in March. His team has won four matches in a row since then, so he says the socks are the reason for the wins. What is wrong with his reasoning, and what else could explain the wins?

You: Tomas is right.

Tutor: If Tomas had also started wearing a new hat in March, would the hat be the reason too?

You: No. He credits the socks only because the wins came after he started wearing them, and the order of events alone does not show a cause. More training, a new player, weaker opponents or plain luck could explain the wins.

Tutor: Yes. That is post hoc reasoning: something happened first, so it gets the credit.

Based on a real step from lesson 3. The tutor's wording varies, and AI can be wrong: the tutor answers from the course material and labels a reply it could not check.

Who this course is for

  • You read opinion pieces, adverts or work emails and want a clear way to check whether the reasons support the claim.
  • You keep hearing names like straw man or slippery slope and want to recognise them in real conversations.
  • You are starting a subject such as philosophy, law or writing that asks you to analyse arguments.
  • You would rather work through short tasks with feedback than read a logic textbook.

Questions about Critical Thinking

Is this a formal logic course?

No. There are no symbols or truth tables. The arguments are short everyday passages about buses, bakeries, club meetings and adverts. Lesson 2 shows one abstract form, "Some X are Y", only to explain what makes an argument valid.

Which fallacies does the course cover?

Six: ad hominem, straw man, false dilemma, appeal to popularity, slippery slope and post hoc reasoning. For each one you see what the trick is and practise telling it apart from the others.

Is the course free?

One lesson in Ai Teacher is free. After that, a subscription opens all lessons. You can pay monthly or yearly in Google Play, and usage limits apply.

Sources

Facts and definitions were checked against these public sources. Lesson text and examples were written independently; no text was adapted.

Start Critical Thinking: Arguments and Fallacies in Ai Teacher

One lesson in the app is free. Ai Teacher is available for Android on Google Play.

Get it on Google Play